Embryos and Flies

“A three-day-old human embryo is a collection of 150 cells called a blastocyst. There are, for the sake of comparison, more than 100,000 cells in the brain of a fly. If our concern is about suffering in this universe, it is rather obvious that we should be more concerned about killing flies than about killing three-day-old human embryos… Many people will argue that the difference between a fly and a three-day-old human embryo is that a three-day-old human embryo is a potential human being. Every cell in your body, given the right manipulations, every cell with a nucleus is now a potential human being. Every time you scratch your nose, you’ve committed a holocaust of potential human beings… Let’s say we grant it that every three-day-old human embryo has a soul worthy of our moral concern. First of all, embryos at this stage can split into identical twins. Is this a case of one soul splitting into two souls? Embryos at this stage can fuse into a chimera. What has happened to the extra human soul in such a case? This is intellectually indefensible, but it’s morally indefensible given that these notions really are prolonging scarcely endurable misery of tens of millions of human beings, and because of the respect we accord religious faith, we can’t have this dialogue in the way that we should. I submit to you that if you think the interests of a three-day-old blastocyst trump the interests of a little girl with spinal cord injuries or a person with full-body burns, your moral intuitions have been obscured by religious metaphysics.”

— Sam Harris, on stem cell research. (via bostonwalkforchoice)

Hm. I’m not sure I agree, but it’s a very interesting and important argument, and one that doesn’t get as much airtime as the alternatives.

(via hypertroll)

Source: bostonwalkforchoice

5921 Notes/ Hide

  1. we-named-the-dog-indiana reblogged this from theoppositeoflamp
  2. ribsintomonkeybars reblogged this from badcgijosh
  3. linzyfillsherquotebook reblogged this from emilyruthless
  4. disastrid reblogged this from petrichoriousparalian and added:
    Logic and reason win again!
  5. rhindelicious reblogged this from akashathekitty
  6. hey--lolita reblogged this from rockabillychlo
  7. jigsawed reblogged this from lovesbitch
  8. lovesbitch reblogged this from rockabillychlo
  9. h0rny-in-a-hearse reblogged this from rockabillychlo
  10. rockabillychlo reblogged this from womanofdarkdesireseb
  11. lifesariverfullofshit reblogged this from bleedingbloodorange
  12. bleedingbloodorange reblogged this from leisee
  13. callanswall reblogged this from lokiitis
  14. arichan373 reblogged this from theeverydaygoth
  15. loveyoulotsliketequilashots reblogged this from escape-prone
  16. handiangel reblogged this from akashathekitty
  17. mieraspeller reblogged this from theoppositeoflamp
  18. escape-prone reblogged this from akashathekitty
  19. akashathekitty reblogged this from msdistress
  20. msdistress reblogged this from womanofdarkdesireseb
  21. queenofthecretaceous reblogged this from uglyorangecouch and added:
    Did I reblog this already? Probably, sorry, Albertan. :P
  22. puppy-suicide reblogged this from andesandsea
  23. momentspassed reblogged this from tardisity
  24. monavale reblogged this from mastersgonnamast
  25. mastersgonnamast reblogged this from pull-to-open
  26. 0tay reblogged this from errortheory
  27. waveunfurled reblogged this from lokiitis
  28. jelly-noodle reblogged this from apoopgirl
  29. thecanticleofthelivingdead reblogged this from womanofdarkdesireseb

Recent comments

Blog comments powered by Disqus
Real Time Web Analytics